Burnham or Mahmood: Lib Dems demand Brexit migration review amid Cabinet splits over cause of small boats crisis

17 Nov 2026

EMBARGO: 0600 Tuesday 17th November 2026

Liberal Democrat Home Affairs Spokesperson, Max Wilkinson MP, is seeking to force the Government’s hand tomorrow by demanding the publication of an honest assessment of how Brexit has changed migration patterns. With Prime Minister Andy Burnham and his own Home Secretary at odds over small boats and immigration, the Liberal Democrats say a divided Cabinet can no longer avoid the question.

The Prime Minister has blamed Brexit for the small boats crisis, saying it arose "because we can't return people", and argued that short-term "revolving door" migration from Europe has given way to long-term settlement in far bigger numbers. But Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood told the Home Affairs Committee in February that blaming the boats on the loss of pre-Brexit arrangements was "too much of a stretch", and reinforced her view in responses to Liberal Democrat questioning in the House of Commons.

The Liberal Democrats have pointed out that the Government is trying to fix the immigration system while its two most senior figures cannot even agree what broke it.

At Report Stage of the Immigration and Asylum Bill on Tuesday [17th November], Liberal Democrat Home Affairs Spokesperson Max Wilkinson MP will push two new clauses:

  • A review of changing migration patterns since Brexit, requiring ministers to report to Parliament within six months on settlement, departures and irregular arrivals before and after the end of free movement, and on the Government's response.
  • UK membership of the EU Migration and Asylum Pact, giving the UK powers to return small boat arrivals to the first EU country they entered.

The review would breach none of Labour's manifesto red lines, leaving Labour MPs free to support the measure.

Liberal Democrat Home Affairs Spokesperson, Max Wilkinson MP, said:

“The Prime Minister blames Brexit for the small boats crisis. His Home Secretary calls that a stretch. Which of them is right and who is running the government’s immigration policy?

“Andy Burnham says he wants an honest discussion about migration and the EU. Our amendment would bring about a review to publish the evidence. What does the government have to hide?

“The Conservatives’ botched Brexit deal wrecked our ability to run a fair, safe and controlled asylum system. Joining the EU’s Migration and Asylum Pact would fix that for a fraction of the cost of this government’s patchwork of deals. It’s time Labour stopped squabbling and admitted it.”

ENDS

Notes to Editors:

  1. Max Wilkinson's letter to the Prime Minister and the text of both new clauses: here.
  2. Max Wilkinson’s new clause would require the Home Secretary, within six months of the Act being passed, to report to Parliament on the balance of migration before and after the end of the Brexit transition period; arrivals under free movement compared with arrivals under the immigration rules since; how many people have settled and how many have left; irregular arrivals before and after, by method of arrival; and the Government's assessment of, and policy response to, Brexit's effect on migration.
  3. Andy Burnham blamed Brexit for the small boats crisis in October 2026: source here. He has also called for an "honest discussion" about immigration since Brexit: source here.
  4. Shabana Mahmood told the Home Affairs Committee in February 2026 that blaming small boats on the loss of the Dublin returns arrangements was "too much of a stretch". Source here.

 


 

 

Desks a computers in front of a wall painted with the bird of liberty

Back to press releases

View
A person using a laptop

Contact the press office

View

This website uses cookies

Please select the types of cookies you want to allow.