For Everyone

For Members

Join from £15/year

About Us

What we stand for

Our Networks

Cases and Decisions

Details of current and historic appeals are available in the below table.

 

Case Reference Date Logged Date Determined Parties Issue(s) Permission to Appeal? Decision Notice
1 15/07/2019 04/08/2020 Bray v Federeal Appeals Panel Request for FAP Decision to be reconsidered out of time. Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
2 14/10/2019 04/05/2020 English Council Executive v Federal Board Constitutional Matter Appeal discontinued by Appellant n/a
3 03/03/2020 04/08/2020 Hayes v English Candidates Committee Constitutional Matter Permission to appeal granted Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
4 16/04/2020 04/07/2020 Pike v Federal Appeals Panel Request for FAP decision to be reconsidered Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
5 03/03/2020 19/11/2020 Roberts, Burree & Waller v Welsh Appeals Panel Election of officers at conference committee Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
6 27/03/2020 14/06/2021 Lock v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
Unknown 16/09/2020 18/11/2020 Powell v Welsh Appeals Panel WAP Jurisdiction challenge Permission to appeal refused Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
7 08/10/2020 27/06/2021 Smith v English Appeals Panel EAP refusal to hear appeal Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
8 29/10/2020 05/04/2021 Potter v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Appeal discontinued by Appellant n/a
9 12/11/2020 20/01/2021 Carter v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Appeal discontinued by Appellant n/a
10 11/12/2020 11/02/2021 Sidhu-Robb v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
11 21/12/2020 16/08/2021 BLAC Liberal Democrats v English Candidates Committee and English Council Rooney Rule Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
12 04/01/2021 04/03/2021 Bray v Federal Joint Candidates Sub-Commitee & Others Constitutional matter Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
13 14/12/2020 14/10/2021 Andersson v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
14 15/12/2020 14/10/2021 Dudhill v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
15 18/01/2021 05/03/2021 Walsh v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
16A 18/02/2021 09/03/2021 Paynter v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
16B 15/03/2021 20/02/2022 Paynter v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
17A 03/03/2021 05/03/2021 Hayes v English Candidates Committee Constitutional impact on approved candidate status in instance of membership break periods (resignation) Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
17B 09/03/2021 01/04/2021 Hayes v English Candidates Committee Constitutional impact on approved candidate status in instance of membership break periods (resignation) Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
18A 11/03/2021 05/04/2021 Sims v English Appeals Panel EAP jurisdiction challenge Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
18B 12/03/2021 05/04/2021 Glaze v English Appeals Panel EAP jurisdiction challenge Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
19 29/03/2021 25/06/2021 Sheller v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
20 26/01/2021 05/02/2021 Howarth v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Appeal discontinued by Appellant n/a
21 28/03/2021 28/06/2021 Goodair v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
22 30/03/2021 27/04/2021 Kumar v Regional Parties Committee Mishandling of complaints under EAP Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
22 13/04/2021 20/07/2021 Hunter v Senior Adjudicators Team Complaints Process Decision Appeal discontinued by Appellant n/a
23 13/05/2021 12/11/2021 Bray v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
24 24/05/2021 13/10/2022 Coelho v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Permission on publication of ruling is pending
25 31/05/2021 16/11/2021 Seabourne v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
26 31/05/2021 23/07/2021 Hayes v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
27 20/06/2021 16/11/2021 Opik v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
28 16/06/2021 06/08/2021 Brown v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
29 16/06/2021 10/08/2021 Scott v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
30 29/06/2021 28/07/2021 Senior Adjudicators Team v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
31 09/07/2021 02/08/2022 Kumar v Local Party Local Party Complaint Decision n/a Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
32 26/07/2021 05/08/2021 Hollinghurst v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
32a* 05/09/2021 30/08/2022 Hayes v Federal Board Forcibly removed from Fed Board Zoom Meeting Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
33 17/09/2021 30/04/2022 McGuffie v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
34 04/10/2021 25/07/2022 Pike v Federal Conference Commitee Consistency of provisions in the Federal Conference Standing Orders with the Federal Constitution Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
35 12/10/2021 15/08/2022 Jones v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
36 15/10/2021 16/08/2022 Grant v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
37 21/10/2021   Hayes v Disciplinary Sub-Group Request for ruling on security of tenure of Senior Adjudicators Permission to appeal granted Hearing is pending
38 22/11/2021 16/08/2022 Jones v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision n/a Permission on publication of ruling is pending
39 21/12/2021 15/08/2022 Hayes v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
40 30/01/2022 01/11/2023 Crowther v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
41 31/01/2022 01/11/2023 Newman v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
42 31/01/2022 01/11/2023 Newman v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
43 06/02/2021 13/07/2022 Eden v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
44 15/02/2022 28/10/2022 AB v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
45 07/03/2022 03/10/2022 Williams v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
46 21/03/2022 28/09/2022 Seabourne v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
47 23/03/2022 28/09/2022 Hayes v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
48 22/03/2022 28/09/2022 Hollinghurst v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
49 03/05/2022   Anon v Senior Adjudicators Team and Standards Office Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
50 24/05/2022 08/09/2022 Lawrie v Scottish Lib Dems Scottish Constitutional Challenge Appeal discontinued by Appellant n/a
51 17/06/2022 18/08/2022 Hayes v English Appeals Panel Procedural appeal against EAP ruling on named Respondent(s) Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
52 13/09/2022 28/10/2022 Campanale v Local and Regional Parties Infringement of preamble rights Permission to appeal refused Permission on publication of ruling is pending
53 11/10/2022 19/09/2023 Holliday v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal is pending Decision available here
54 11/11/2022 10/07/2023 Webster v Federal Returning Officer Conduct of Returning Officer Permission to appeal granted Decision available here
55 19/08/2022 30/03/2023 White v Federal Appeals Panel Request for ruling on juridiction of FAP in Case 35. Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
56 29/11/2022 01/03/2023 Anon v Federal Returning Officer Dismissal by the Federal Elections Returning Officer of a complaint Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
57 30/11/2022 01/03/2023 Anon v Federal Returning Officer Dismissal by the Federal Elections Returning Officer of a complaint Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
58 31/01/2023   Johnston v Federal Audit and Scrutiny Committee & Chief Executive Officer Omission of FASC reports to members Permission to appeal granted Hearing is pending
59 04/04/2023   Davey v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal is pending n/a
60 06/04/2023   Potts v Complaints Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal is pending n/a
61 13/06/2023 12/03/2024 Scott v Review Panel Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal refused Decision available here
62 23/09/2023   North v Standards Office Complaints Process Decision Permission to appeal granted Decision/hearing is pending
63 10/12/2023   Bliss v Federal Conference Committee FCC Decision Permission to appeal is pending n/a
64 22/01/2024   Johnston v Federal Board Federal Board decision Permission to appeal is pending n/a
65 30/01/2024   Johnston v Federal Returning Officer & Federal Deputy Returning Officer Returning Officer Decision Permission to appeal is pending n/a

*Due to a sequencing error, Case 32(a) was not included within the referencing system however in chronological order is the next case received. It is in no way linked to Case 32.