Cases and Decisions

Details of current and historic appeals are available in the below table.

Case Reference	Date Logged	Date Determined	Parties	Issue(s)	Permission to Appeal?	Decision Notice
1	15/07/2019	03/02/2021	Bray v Federeal Appeals Panel	Request for FAP Decision to be reconsidered out of time.	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
2	14/10/2019	04/05/2021	English Council Executive v Federal Board	Constitutional Matter	Appeal discontinued by Appellant	n/a
3	03/03/2020	04/08/2020	Hayes v English Candidates Committee	Constitutional Matter	Permission to appeal granted	Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
4	16/04/2020	04/07/2020	Pike v Federal Appeals Panel	Request for FAP decision to be reconsidered	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
5	03/03/2020	19/11/2020	Roberts, Burree & Waller v Welsh Appeals Panel	Election of officers at conference committee	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
6	27/03/2020	14/06/2021	Lock v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
Unknown	16/09/2020	18/11/2020	Powell v Welsh Appeals Panel	WAP Jurisdiction challenge	Permission to appeal refused	Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
7	08/10/2020	27/06/2021	Smith v English Appeals Panel	EAP refusal to hear appeal	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
8	29/10/2020	05/04/2021	Potter v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Appeal discontinued by Appellant	n/a
9	12/11/2020	20/01/2021	Carter v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Appeal discontinued by Appellant	n/a
10	11/12/2020	11/02/2021	Sidhu-Robb v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
11	21/12/2020	16/08/2021	BLAC Liberal Democrats v English Candidates Committee and English Council	Rooney Rule	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
12	04/01/2021	04/03/2021	Bray v Federal Joint Candidates Sub-Commitee & Others	Constitutional matter	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
13	14/12/2020	14/10/2021	Andersson v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
14	15/12/2020	14/10/2021	Dudhill v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
15	18/01/2021	05/03/2021	Walsh v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
16A	18/02/2021	09/03/2021	Paynter v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
16B	15/03/2021	20/02/2022	Paynter v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
17A	03/03/2021	05/03/2021	Hayes v English Candidates Committee	Constitutional impact on approved candidate status in instance of membership break periods (resignation)	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
17B	09/03/2021	01/04/2021	Hayes v English Candidates Committee	Constitutional impact on approved candidate status in instance of membership break periods (resignation)	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
18A	11/03/2021	05/04/2021	Sims v English Appeals Panel	EAP jurisdiction challenge	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
18B	12/03/2021	05/04/2021	Glaze v English Appeals Panel	EAP jurisdiction challenge	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
19	29/03/2021	29/06/2021	Sheller v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
20	26/01/2021	05/02/2021	Howarth v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Appeal discontinued by Appellant	n/a
21	28/03/2021	28/06/2021	Goodair v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
22	30/03/2021	27/04/2021	Kumar v Regional Parties Committee	Mishandling of complaints under EAP	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
22	13/04/2021	20/07/2021	Hunter v Senior Adjudicators Team	Complaints Process Decision	Appeal discontinued by Appellant	n/a
23	13/05/2021	12/11/2021	Bray v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
24	24/05/2021	13/10/2022	Coelho v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
25	31/05/2021	16/11/2021	Seabourne v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
26	31/05/2021	23/07/2021	Hayes v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
27	20/06/2021	16/11/2021	Opik v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
28	16/06/2021	06/08/2021	Brown v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
29	16/06/2021	10/08/2021	Scott v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
30	29/06/2021	28/07/2021	Senior Adjudicators Team v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
31	09/07/2021	02/08/2022	Kumar v Local Party	Local Party Complaint Decision	n/a	Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
32	26/07/2021	12/08/2021	Hollinghurst v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
32a*	05/09/2021	26/08/2022	Hayes v Federal Board	Forcibly removed from Fed Board Zoom Meeting	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
33	17/09/2021	30/04/2022	McGuffie v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
34	04/10/2021	25/07/2022	Pike v Federal Conference Commitee	Consistency of provisions in the Federal Conference Standing Orders with the Federal Constitution	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
35	12/10/2021	15/08/2022	Jones v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
36	15/10/2021	26/08/2022	Grant v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
37	21/10/2021	TBC	Hayes v Disciplinary Sub-Group	Request for ruling on security of tenure of Senior Adjudicators	Permission to appeal granted	Hearing is pending
38	22/11/2021	16/08/2022	Jones v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	n/a	Permission on publication of ruling is pending
39	21/12/2021	15/08/2022	Hayes v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
40	30/01/2022	24/10/2023	Crowther v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
41	31/01/2022	24/10/2023	Newman v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
42	31/01/2022	24/10/2023	Newman v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
43	06/02/2021	13/07/2022	Eden v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
44	15/02/2022	28/10/2022	AB v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
45	07/03/2022	03/10/2022	Williams v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
46	21/03/2022	28/09/2022	Seabourne v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
47	23/03/2022	28/09/2022	Hayes v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
48	22/03/2022	28/09/2022	Hollinghurst v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
49	03/05/2022	25/04/2023	Anon v Senior Adjudicators Team and Standards Office	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Permission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
50	24/05/2022	08/09/2022	Lawrie v Scottish Lib Dems	Scottish Constitutional Challenge	Appeal discontinued by Appellant	n/a
51	17/06/2022	18/08/2022	Hayes v English Appeals Panel	Procedural appeal against EAP ruling on named Respondent(s)	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
52	13/09/2022	28/10/2022	Campanale v Local and Regional Parties	Infringement of preamble rights	Permission to appeal refused	Permission on publication of ruling is pending
53	11/10/2022	19/09/2023	Holliday v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
54	11/11/2022	10/07/2023	Webster v Federal Returning Officer	Conduct of Returning Officer	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
55	19/08/2022	30/03/2023	White v Federal Appeals Panel	Request for ruling on jurisdiction of FAP in Case 35.	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
56	29/11/2022	24/12/2022	Anon v Federal Returning Officer	Dismissal by the Federal Elections Returning Officer of a complaint	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
57	30/11/2022	24/12/2022	Anon v Federal Returning Officer	Dismissal by the Federal Elections Returning Officer of a complaint	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
58	31/01/2023	TBC	Johnston v Federal Audit and Scrutiny Committee & Chief Executive Officer	Omission of FASC reports to members	Permission to appeal granted	Hearing is pending
59	04/04/2023	09/04/2025	Davey v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
60	06/04/2023	09/04/2025	Potts v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
61	13/06/2023	12/03/2024	Scott v Review Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
62	23/09/2023	24/09/2024	North v Standards Office	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Permission on publication of ruling is pending
63	10/12/2023	12/09/2024	Bliss v Federal Conference Committee	FCC Decision	Permission to appeal refused	Decision available here
64	22/01/2024	25/02/2025	Johnston v Federal Board	Federal Board Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Decision available here
65	30/01/2024	TBC	Johnston v Federal Returning Officer & Federal Deputy Returning Officer	Returning Officer Decision	Permission to appeal granted	Hearing is pending
66	22/03/2024	TBC	Makhapila v Complaints Panel	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal is pending	n/a
67	02/06/2024	TBC	Keynes v Federal Returning Officer (FRO)	Returning Officer Decision	Permission to appeal is pending	n/a
68	03/06/2024	TBC	Johnston v Federal Returning Officer (FRO)	Returning Officer Decision	Permission to appeal is pending	n/a
69	21/06/2024	24/06/2024	Beavan v Senior Adjudicators Team (SAT)	Complaints Process Decision	Permission to appeal refused	n/a
70	12/11/2024	TBC	Barnsdale v Federal Returning Officer (FRO)	Returning Officer Decision	Permission to appeal is pending	n/a
71	17/01/2025	TBC	Bliss v Young Liberals	Young Liberal Complaint Decision	Permission to appeal is pending	n/a
72	16/04/2025	TBC	Hobson v Welsh Candidates Committee	Welsh Candidates Chair Decision	Permission to appeal is pending	n/a

*Due to a sequencing error, Case 32(a) was not included within the referencing system however in chronological order is the next case received. It is in no way linked to Case 32.

For Everyone

For Members

About Us

What we stand for

Our Networks

Cases and Decisions