Cases and Decisions

Details of current and historic appeals are available in the below table.

 

Case ReferenceDate LoggedDate DeterminedPartiesIssue(s)Permission to Appeal?Decision Notice
115/07/201903/02/2021Bray v Federeal Appeals PanelRequest for FAP Decision to be reconsidered out of time.Permission to appeal refusedDecision available here
214/10/201904/05/2021English Council Executive v Federal BoardConstitutional MatterAppeal discontinued by Appellantn/a
303/03/202004/08/2020Hayes v English Candidates CommitteeConstitutional MatterPermission to appeal grantedPermission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
416/04/202004/07/2020Pike v Federal Appeals PanelRequest for FAP decision to be reconsideredPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
503/03/202019/11/2020Roberts, Burree & Waller v Welsh Appeals PanelElection of officers at conference committeePermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
627/03/202014/06/2021Lock v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
Unknown16/09/202018/11/2020Powell v Welsh Appeals PanelWAP Jurisdiction challengePermission to appeal refusedPermission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
708/10/202027/06/2021Smith v English Appeals PanelEAP refusal to hear appealPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
829/10/202005/04/2021Potter v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionAppeal discontinued by Appellantn/a
912/11/202020/01/2021Carter v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionAppeal discontinued by Appellantn/a
1011/12/202011/02/2021Sidhu-Robb v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
1121/12/202016/08/2021BLAC Liberal Democrats v English Candidates Committee and English CouncilRooney RulePermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
1204/01/202104/03/2021Bray v Federal Joint Candidates Sub-Commitee & OthersConstitutional matterPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
1314/12/202014/10/2021Andersson v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
1415/12/202014/10/2021Dudhill v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
1518/01/202105/03/2021Walsh v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
16A18/02/202109/03/2021Paynter v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
16B15/03/202120/02/2022Paynter v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
17A03/03/202105/03/2021Hayes v English Candidates CommitteeConstitutional impact on approved candidate status in instance of membership break periods (resignation)Permission to appeal refusedDecision available here
17B09/03/202101/04/2021Hayes v English Candidates CommitteeConstitutional impact on approved candidate status in instance of membership break periods (resignation)Permission to appeal grantedDecision available here
18A11/03/202105/04/2021Sims v English Appeals PanelEAP jurisdiction challengePermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
18B12/03/202105/04/2021Glaze v English Appeals PanelEAP jurisdiction challengePermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
1929/03/202129/06/2021Sheller v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2026/01/202105/02/2021Howarth v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionAppeal discontinued by Appellantn/a
2128/03/202128/06/2021Goodair v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2230/03/202127/04/2021Kumar v Regional Parties CommitteeMishandling of complaints under EAPPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
2213/04/202120/07/2021Hunter v Senior Adjudicators TeamComplaints Process DecisionAppeal discontinued by Appellantn/a
2313/05/202112/11/2021Bray v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2424/05/202113/10/2022Coelho v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2531/05/202116/11/2021Seabourne v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2631/05/202123/07/2021Hayes v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2720/06/202116/11/2021Opik v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2816/06/202106/08/2021Brown v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
2916/06/202110/08/2021Scott v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedPermission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
3029/06/202128/07/2021Senior Adjudicators Team v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
3109/07/202102/08/2022Kumar v Local PartyLocal Party Complaint Decisionn/aPermission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
3226/07/202112/08/2021Hollinghurst v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
32a*05/09/202126/08/2022Hayes v Federal BoardForcibly removed from Fed Board Zoom MeetingPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
3317/09/202130/04/2022McGuffie v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
3404/10/202125/07/2022Pike v Federal Conference CommiteeConsistency of provisions in the Federal Conference Standing Orders with the Federal ConstitutionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
3512/10/202115/08/2022Jones v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
3615/10/202126/08/2022Grant v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
3721/10/2021TBCHayes v Disciplinary Sub-GroupRequest for ruling on security of tenure of Senior AdjudicatorsPermission to appeal grantedHearing is pending
3822/11/202116/08/2022Jones v Complaints PanelComplaints Process Decisionn/aPermission on publication of ruling is pending
3921/12/202115/08/2022Hayes v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
4030/01/202224/10/2023Crowther v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
4131/01/202224/10/2023Newman v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
4231/01/202224/10/2023Newman v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
4306/02/202113/07/2022Eden v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
4415/02/202228/10/2022AB v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
4507/03/202203/10/2022Williams v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
4621/03/202228/09/2022Seabourne v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
4723/03/202228/09/2022Hayes v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
4822/03/202228/09/2022Hollinghurst v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
4903/05/202225/04/2023Anon v Senior Adjudicators Team and Standards OfficeComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedPermission for the appeal not to be published was also granted
5024/05/202208/09/2022Lawrie v Scottish Lib DemsScottish Constitutional ChallengeAppeal discontinued by Appellantn/a
5117/06/202218/08/2022Hayes v English Appeals PanelProcedural appeal against EAP ruling on named Respondent(s)Permission to appeal refusedDecision available here
5213/09/202228/10/2022Campanale v Local and Regional PartiesInfringement of preamble rightsPermission to appeal refusedPermission on publication of ruling is pending
5311/10/202219/09/2023Holliday v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
5411/11/202210/07/2023Webster v Federal Returning OfficerConduct of Returning OfficerPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
5519/08/202230/03/2023White v Federal Appeals PanelRequest for ruling on jurisdiction of FAP in Case 35.Permission to appeal refusedDecision available here
5629/11/202224/12/2022Anon v Federal Returning OfficerDismissal by the Federal Elections Returning Officer of a complaintPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
5730/11/202224/12/2022Anon v Federal Returning OfficerDismissal by the Federal Elections Returning Officer of a complaintPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
5831/01/2023TBCJohnston v Federal Audit and Scrutiny Committee & Chief Executive OfficerOmission of FASC reports to membersPermission to appeal grantedHearing is pending
5904/04/202309/04/2025Davey v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
6006/04/202309/04/2025Potts v Complaints PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
6113/06/202312/03/2024Scott v Review PanelComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
6223/09/202324/09/2024North v Standards OfficeComplaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal grantedPermission on publication of ruling is pending
6310/12/202312/09/2024Bliss v Federal Conference CommitteeFCC DecisionPermission to appeal refusedDecision available here
6422/01/202425/02/2025Johnston v Federal BoardFederal Board DecisionPermission to appeal grantedDecision available here
6530/01/2024TBCJohnston v Federal Returning Officer & Federal Deputy Returning OfficerReturning Officer DecisionPermission to appeal grantedHearing is pending
6622/03/2024TBCMakhapila v Complaints PanelComplaints Process Decision Permission to appeal is pendingn/a
6702/06/2024TBCKeynes v Federal Returning Officer (FRO)Returning Officer DecisionPermission to appeal is pendingn/a
6803/06/2024TBCJohnston v Federal Returning Officer (FRO)Returning Officer DecisionPermission to appeal is pendingn/a
6921/06/202424/06/2024Beavan v Senior Adjudicators Team (SAT)Complaints Process DecisionPermission to appeal refusedn/a
7012/11/2024TBCBarnsdale v Federal Returning Officer (FRO)Returning Officer DecisionPermission to appeal is pendingn/a
7117/01/2025TBCBliss v Young LiberalsYoung Liberal Complaint DecisionPermission to appeal is pendingn/a
7216/04/2025TBCHobson v Welsh Candidates CommitteeWelsh Candidates Chair DecisionPermission to appeal is pendingn/a

*Due to a sequencing error, Case 32(a) was not included within the referencing system however in chronological order is the next case received. It is in no way linked to Case 32.

This website uses cookies

Like most websites, this site uses cookies. Some are required to make it work, while others are used for statistical or marketing purposes. If you choose not to allow cookies some features may not be available, such as content from other websites. Please read our Cookie Policy for more information.

Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the website to function properly.
Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us to understand how our visitors use our website.
Marketing cookies are used by third parties or publishers to display personalized advertisements. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.